The Jeff Pulver Blog: When Arbitrage is a Good Thing, or at Least a Wake Up Call -- The Dispute Over Access Charges for Conference Call Traffic Terminating in Iowa

« IP Communications: Part of the Fabric of our Lives | Main | Project Pedal: Episode 4 - (by Mike Ambs, winner of Network2 Contest) »

April 13, 2007

When Arbitrage is a Good Thing, or at Least a Wake Up Call -- The Dispute Over Access Charges for Conference Call Traffic Terminating in Iowa

So, I am hearing an escalating furor regarding the battle between Iowa rural telcos and conference-calling companies on the one side and the major telcos including AT&T, Qwest and Sprint on the other side over the rates for terminating traffic in Iowa. Perhaps the issue will come to a head this week when parties meet at the FCC. Perhaps this is the incentive the carriers and the FCC need to finally move away from the unworkable, patchwork, intercarrier compensation regime.

For me, it's interesting to see the shoe on the other foot. Although the rural carriers have always had VERY strong allies at the FCC, in Congress and in the state commissions, so have the largest telcos. Now that they are going head-to-head, perhaps the largest telcos are feeling a little vulnerable and recognize the absurdities of the kluged and archaic inter-carrier compensation regime.

The small carriers seem to have the law on their side. As best I can tell, if their rates have been properly filed with the Commission, the telcos must terminate traffic to these rural carriers and conference centers. There was some effort to block traffic to these rural LECs and conference calling centers, but I think the FCC has historically ruled that carriers cannot block traffic if the tariffed rates were legally filed and unchallenged. That is not to say the law is right. But, it is a system that the largest telcos have allowed to persist for ten years, in part, because they have typically been the net beneficiaries. And, in those rare situations where they have been the net losers, that have generally succeeded in stalling or undermining or reversing the payment process (e.g., the recip comp for ISP-bound traffic battles; the phantom traffic and FX traffic scenarios; the charging of access rates, rather than recip comp or no rate, for VoIP traffic).

This Iowa traffic termination situation, to me, is a clear demonstration that the current inter-carrier compensation regime is unsustainable. This is an instance where Qwest, at&t and Sprint are the net payors and it is they who are screaming fraud, bloody murder, and the dirtiest of words - "arbitrage". Well, it is arbitrage, but so what? Arbitrage is just real world evidence of the market failure of an inter-carrier compensation that the biggest telcos have propped up for ten years. When the inter-carrier compensation regime ensured they were the net recipient of revenue, that regime was great. In the few instances where the biggest telcos have been the net payors, they have screamed fraud and arbitrage. Well, they cannot perpetuate a system that only allows for arbitrage and usurious rents when they are the net beneficiary. Perhaps this is the final impetus all the carriers need to come to the table and finally break the stalemate and allow their friends at the FCC to pass an omnibus reform of the inter-carrier compensation regime that will move to either bill and keep or a compensation scheme that more adequately reflects costs.

Tags: USF, FCC, VoIP, AT&T, intercarrier compensation, Qwest, Sprint, Access Charges, Iowa, Jeff Pulver

Posted by jeff on April 13, 2007 06:01 PM | Permalink

Additional resources: #140conf events | Watch the Jeff Pulver Show | Jeff's Qik Videos

Comments

CIGNA health insurance company 330 million U.S. dollars in the fourth quarter than-expected profit wow gold Life Home Health Guide: This is 10 kinds of people tend to suffer from diabetes,wow power leveling Net purchase New Year to consider the health standards,cheap wow gold Maintenance of 14 strokes to make your health even more young,buy wow gold Maintenance of 14 strokes to make your health even more young,World of Warcraft Gold 2009 Top Ten News of Chinese medicine wow gold Life Home Health Guide: Simple regimen make you live longer,wow power leveling Life Home Health Guide: Family Story, diabetes prevention and treatment of children,cheap wow gold Health Industry in Hebei Province will be playing the "10 card",buy wow gold Easy Weight Loss OL delicious healthy recipes to lose weight,World of Warcraft Gold Food packaging low-quality products are hazardous to health crisis-ridden

10.02.06T

Posted by: WOW GOLD at February 5, 2010 10:00 PM

10.02.06T

Posted by: WOW GOLD at February 5, 2010 09:58 PM

Long absent, soon forgotten.

Posted by: Rhinestone Jewelry at February 4, 2010 04:03 AM

At http://www.progiftstore.com, you can get the best quality swiss replica watches with the lowest price. In progiftstore, you can buy replica watches with a grrat discount.

Posted by: Jason at February 3, 2010 12:50 AM

The definition of a lucky man and a woman replica watches from the left point

to the definition of the points table will bring.
From rolex watches to see men

and women actually love talking about the definition of euphony, to my

mind, rather, meaning is about love.
From the reports of men and women means that all the dependencies and

the second one I love datejust lady watchestogether

forever.
From the reports of men and women means you are not a permanent sense

of time.
From time to see the men and women every day to see the true meaning,

see, and clear, and apparently I were you.

Posted by: emily at February 2, 2010 08:01 AM

The definition of a lucky man and a woman replica watches from the left point

to the definition of the points table will bring.
From rolex watches to see men

and women actually love talking about the definition of euphony, to my

mind, rather, meaning is about love.
From the reports of men and women means that all the dependencies and

the second one I love datejust lady watchestogether

forever.
From the reports of men and women means you are not a permanent sense

of time.
From time to see the men and women every day to see the true meaning,

see, and clear, and apparently I were you.

Posted by: emily at February 2, 2010 08:00 AM

The definition of a lucky man and a woman replica watches from the left point

to the definition of the points table will bring.
From rolex watches to see men

and women actually love talking about the definition of euphony, to my

mind, rather, meaning is about love.
From the reports of men and women means that all the dependencies and

the second one I love datejust lady watchestogether

forever.
From the reports of men and women means you are not a permanent sense

of time.
From time to see the men and women every day to see the true meaning,

see, and clear, and apparently I were you.

Posted by: emily at February 2, 2010 07:57 AM

Posted by: replica rolex at November 16, 2009 01:09 AM

http://www.wholesalewatches.com.cn/
http://www.wholesalewatches.com.cn/bangle-watches/
http://www.wholesalewatches.com.cn/watch-faces/
http://www.wholesalewatches.com.cn/wrist-watches/
http://www.wholesalewatches.com.cn/beaded-watches/

Posted by: Watch faces at November 4, 2009 02:11 AM

Replica">Replica">http://www.onlineshopsreviews.com/">Replica Ugg Boots For Sale
Fake">Fake">http://www.onlineshopsreviews.com/">Fake Ugg Boots For Sale
Lace">Lace">http://www.onlineshopsreviews.com/">Lace Up Ugg Boots For Sale
Replica">Replica">http://famousbrandshop.com/christian-louboutin/">Replica Christian Louboutin Shoes on sale
Knock">Knock">http://famousbrandshop.com/christian-louboutin/">Knock Off Christian Louboutin Boots Sale
Discount">Discount">http://famousbrandshop.com/christian-louboutin/">Discount Christian Louboutin Shoes Review
Replica">Replica">http://uggboots-shop.com/">Replica Ugg Boots On Sale
Fake">Fake">http://uggboots-shop.com/">Fake Ugg Boots For Sale
Knit">Knit">http://uggboots-shop.com/">Knit Fake Ugg Boots
Kids">Kids">http://uggboots-shop.com/">Kids Ugg Boots For Sale
Wholesale">Wholesale">http://uggboots-shop.com/">Wholesale Ugg Boots
China">China">http://www.abercrombie-club.com/">China Wholesale Handbags
Discount">Discount">http://www.tiffanyjewelryshops.com/">Discount Tiffany Jewelry Sale
replica">replica">http://www.famousbrandbag.com/">replica handbags
2009">2009">http://www.famousbrandbag.com/">2009 Handbags
Handbags">Handbags">http://www.famousbrandbag.com/">Handbags Sale
True">True">http://www.famousbrandbag.com/True-Religion-Jeans-True-Religion-Women-Jeans/c144_146/index.html">True Religion Women

Posted by: Knock Off Christian Louboutin Boots Sale at November 2, 2009 03:33 AM

Posted by: Wholesale jewelry at October 20, 2009 03:00 AM

Posted by: luxury watches at October 11, 2009 06:02 AM

[url=http://www.zimbio.com/health-care+for+all/articles/A5lbeLvVB-L/BuyCheapViagra]buy viagra[/url]

[url=http://www.propeller.com/member/buy-cheap-viagra1]buy viagra[/url]

[url=http://sharepointmx.mvps.org/members/Buy_2D00_CHEAP_2D00_VIAGRA1.aspx]buy viagra[/url]

[url=http://www.cnet.com/profile/buycheapviagra]buy viagra[/url]

[url=http://slisweb.sjsu.edu/sl/index.php/User:Loadedmovies]buy viagra[/url]

[url=http://wiki.hudson-ci.org/users/viewuserprofile.action?username=buy-cheap-viagra]buy cheap viagra[/url]
[url=http://lowech.writing.gvsu.edu/fa07/351/node/2673]buy cheap viagra[/url]

Posted by: buy cheap viagra at September 29, 2009 11:03 AM

provide you the best quality,selection and price you can only find in the top specialty

stores,Keeping you abreast of the lastest trends and providing the convenience of shopping from

home.
[URL=http://www.go4bagtrade.com]replica designer handbags[/URL],provide you the best

quality,selection and price you can only find in the top specialty stores,Keeping you abreast of the

lastest trends and providing the convenience of shopping from home.[URL=http://www.go4bagtrade.com]

replica handbags [/URL]

Posted by: replica handbags at September 8, 2009 02:22 PM

www.replicaseller.com As a professional replica watch dealer we are 100% committed to your satisfaction. http://www.replicaseller.com/
http://www.brandlike.com/
http://www.replicaseller.com/montblanc/
http://www.replicaseller.com/breitling/
http://www.replicaseller.com/tagheuer/
http://www.replicaseller.com/rolex/

Posted by: replica watches at August 26, 2009 02:32 PM

Posted by: replica watches at August 26, 2009 02:28 PM

http://www.fantastic-replica.net

Posted by: wwabn at August 20, 2009 10:43 PM

The players are in a better position than any one else in the Telco industry

Posted by: wholesale jewelry at June 27, 2009 11:55 PM

http://jewelrybeautif.pressword.com
http://jewelryshowup.pressword.com
http://beadsale.pressword.com
http://sunnybeads.pressword.com
http://discountjewelry13.pressword.com
http://chinesejewelry56.pressword.com
http://chinesejewelry23.pressword.com
http://nicejewelry23.pressword.com
http://jadejewelry23.pressword.com
http://goodjewelry23.pressword.com
http://jewelryshops19.pressword.com
http://fantasticjewelry.pressword.com

Posted by: rwwefwe at June 5, 2009 03:34 AM

When the wolf [url=http://www.game4power.com/]wow gold [/url] finally found the hole [url=http://www.game4power.com]Buy Wow Gold[/url] in the chimney he [url=http://www.wowgoldone.com/]Cheap WoW Gold[/url] crawled down and KERSPLASH right into that kettle of water [url=http://www.wowgoldone.com/]cheapest wow gold[/url] and that was the end of his troubles with the big bad wolf.

[url=http://www.game4power.com/]game4power[/url],[url=http://www.game4power.com/buy-gold/]buy cheap wow gold [/url]

The next day the [url=http://www.game4power.com/buy-gold/]wow gold cheap[/url] little pig invited his mother over . She said "You see it is just as [url=http://www.game4power.com/]buy gold wow[/url]I told you. The way to [url=http://www.
itemchannel.com]Wow Gold[/url]get along in the world is to do things as well as you can." Fortunately for that [url=http://www.itemchannel.com]world of warcraft gold [/url] little pig, he [url=http://www.game4power.com/buy-gold]Cheapest wow Gold[/url]learned that lesson. And he just lived happily ever after!

Posted by: Wow Gold at May 22, 2009 01:41 AM

When the Wow Gold wolf finally found the Buy Wow Goldhole in the chimney he crawled wow gold cheap down and KERSPLASH right into that kettle of water and that was cheapest wow gold the end of his troubles with the big bad wolf.

game4power,buy cheap wow gold

The next day the cheap wow gold buy gold wow little pig invited his mother over . She said "You see it is just as I told you. The way to wow goldget along in the world is to do world of warcraft gold things as well as you can." Fortunately for that little pig, he cheapest wow gold learned that lesson. And he just lived happily ever after!

Posted by: Wow Gold at May 22, 2009 01:40 AM

http://wwww.casijewelry.com

Posted by: silver jewelry at May 20, 2009 03:13 AM

Wholesale Silver jewelry ,pearl jewelry,pearls at http://wwww.casijewelry.com

Posted by: pearl jewelry at May 20, 2009 02:14 AM

wholesale pearl jewelry http://www.wspearl.com
wholesale gemstone beads http://www.hibeads.com

Posted by: pearl jewelry at December 22, 2008 10:09 AM

http://www.seo-cai.cn
http://www.enwowgold.com
http://www.haowowgold.com
http://www.u-waytours.com
http://www.wowgoldau.cn

Posted by: tibet tour at December 10, 2008 09:56 PM

http://www.56jewelry.com/
http://www.tangjewelry.com

Posted by: wholesale jewelry at December 3, 2008 01:30 AM

The big players are in a better position than any one else in the Telco industry

Posted by: Tarus at November 8, 2007 09:26 AM

The issue here is exactly what Jeff says. The CLECs have the law but the Bells have the gold. Golden rule. he who has the gold rules. But the CLEC's did the smart thing and hired Kelly and Drye, or Jon Canis. There is no backing down on this fight. The bells will pay 110%. Many of these companies will take it all the way, they have the law. Hope AT&T reaps what they sow, they did this thing years ago.

Posted by: CLEC at September 5, 2007 10:38 PM

John, how does bidding on rural coverage, which has been suggested as a way to deal with the rising cost of USF, deal with ICC?

Posted by: Anonymous at April 16, 2007 01:46 PM

Agree completely with your analysis. The hopeful idea is that this will force the FCC to reform the intercarrier rates in a sensible way. The idea that's been floating around for bidding on rural coverage is one possible method to keep the rates from being artificially too high.

Of course, if the big companies end up being allowed to just block then that would be disastrous. It does pretty clearly seem to violate the FCC regulations. Though the FCC regulations at the same time prevent them from directly passing on these intercarrier charges; they're forced to spread them around.

Posted by: John Thacker at April 15, 2007 10:07 PM

Hello All:

Jeff has the correct legal and regulatory tack. In a nutshell no carrier--even one headed by Ed Whitacre--can unilaterally establish itself as judge, jury and executioner. As a common carrier still subject to at least some provisions in Title II of the Communications Act, all wireline and wireless carriers have to interconnect with other similarly situated carriers. No carrier can unilaterally decide to refuse to hand off traffic to another carrier, because the termination costs are "too high." If AT&T had a problem with Iowa carriers' access charges exceeding the NECA safe habor rate, it should have filed a formal opposition.
In the longer term arbitrage opportunities will abate as occurred with international callback. Both market-based and regulatory remedies will occur, but not if a carrier can short circuit the process.

Posted by: Rob Frieden at April 14, 2007 05:10 PM

I've been blogging about this myself, though I liked somebody else's characterization of this myself -- you are forced to pick sides between a bad company and a worse company.

The right answer is the internet model. Each party pays for their line to the middle, and you don't do settlement payments, especially regulated non-negotiable settlement payments. I mean imagine how the Internet would work if packets to Iowa cost 10 times what packets to New York cost? If we want to subsidize people in Iowa's expensive lines into the cloud, then we can do that, but nobody would put a conference bridge there deliberately to take advantage of loopholes.

http://ideas.4brad.com/whoops-freeconference-coms-pants-fall

Posted by: Brad Templeton at April 13, 2007 10:50 PM

It doesn't small carriers seem to have the law on their side, the big ones will allways win. That's the law.

Olavo

Posted by: voip at April 13, 2007 08:06 PM

April 13, 2007

When Arbitrage is a Good Thing, or at Least a Wake Up Call -- The Dispute Over Access Charges for Conference Call Traffic Terminating in Iowa

Comments

Post a comment